I launched a Substack the other day. Below is my first article. I’ll keep this blog because it has so many of my sermons. And I’ll likely post my Substack articles here as well. You can find my Substack here: https://substack.com/@greggcaruso.
For the last few days, I have been reading a short biography of Augustine of Hippo (354–430 AD), who (as most people know) was a prominent theologian and philosopher, widely regarded as one of the most influential figures in Christian thought beyond whom we encounter in the Christian Scriptures. Augustine is also highly regarded by all three of the major branches of Christian thought and theology—Catholic, Protestant, and Eastern Orthodox. While (apparently) he doesn’t use the phrase “sovereign joy” as a literal term, the concept is central to his theology.
The idea of searching for otherworldly joy is, I believe, essential in this tumultuous and often sickening season of American life.
While I am by no means an Augustinian scholar, based on previous reading and with the help of some further study, a short overview of Augustine’s doctrine of “sovereign joy” could be:
God desires to be the highest and presiding joy of the human heart, and every other joy is meant to be enjoyed in reference to His wonder, beauty, mercy, and grace.
A few core paradigms include:
- Ordered loves (ordo amoris [1]). Augustine says sin isn’t loving bad things; it’s loving good things out of order. When joy is “sovereign” in the wrong place (career, family, success, even ministry), it disorders the soul. God alone is meant to be our supreme joy. [2]
- Use vs. enjoy (uti vs. frui). We are to enjoy God and use everything else in love toward God. When we try to enjoy created things as ultimate, they can’t bear the weight, and they end up (ultimately) disappointing us.
- Restless hearts. “Our hearts are restless until they rest in You” (an often quoted prayer of Augustine). That rest is joy grounded in God’s unchanging goodness and grace, not our circumstances.
- Freedom and stability. Sovereign joy in God frees us from being emotionally ruled by loss, success, or suffering. Lesser joys come and go; the supreme joy remains (e.g., the difference between happiness, which is circumstantial, and true residential joy).
Augustine is offering an alternative to both hedonism and stoicism. He seems to be saying joy matters deeply—but it has to be anchored in the one reality that won’t collapse under pressure. When God is the ruling joy of what our heart longs for, everything else finds its proper place.
I have been a follower of Jesus for over 50 years, and this remains a considerable and ongoing challenge for me.
If you would like to explore Augustine’s writing, looking for how he writes about his overarching joy, here are some places to look…
1. City of God (Book XV & XIX)
This is probably the most explicit…
- City of God XV.22—Augustine contrasts the two cities as being formed by two loves: love of God vs. love of self.
- City of God XIX.13–14—Augustine defines virtue as rightly ordered love (ordo amoris).
2. On Christian Doctrine (De Doctrina Christiana, Book I)
Probably the most pastoral explanation. This is where Augustine explains that only God is to be enjoyed for His own sake.
3. Confessions
More experiential than systematic.
- Book I—The “restless heart” theme (desire aimed wrongly).
- Books II & X—Disordered desire, especially around pleasure, ambition, and self-love.
4. Enchiridion (chapters 28–33)
A concise summary of faith, hope, and love that assumes ordered love as the grace-initiated and empowered moral core of our personal philosophy of life.
[1] We named our eldest, a daughter, Amaris, based on the premise of God’s gracious promise.[2] While Augustine (seemingly) never offers a detailed unpacking of “Ordo Amoris,” it is a consistent thread throughout his writing.

